dxy logo
首页丁香园病例库全部版块
搜索
登录

SCI编辑拒稿后建议修改后重投

医师 · 发布于 1 天前 · 来自 Android · IP 福建福建
348 浏览


如题投稿后主编给拒了但是说可以重写后再投,并列出了编辑的comments,麻烦大家看看,谢谢“Comments by the Editor: There seems to be misalignment between the manuscript content and the Abstract. In the Abstract, you refer to a foetal karyotype, but no investigation seems to have been carried out on foetal material. Your manuscript also presents a high word similarity to previously published work. Please consider rewriting your manuscript and resubmitting it as a short case report. No need to indicate 'literature review' in the title, as the information you have provided is to provide context and does not classify as a literature review.”

1.There seems to be misalignment between the manuscript content and the Abstract. In the Abstract, you refer to a foetal karyotype, but no investigation seems to have been carried out on foetal material. 这个我觉得是编辑没有仔细看内容,其实abstract和content是相符的。。。

2.Your manuscript also presents a high word similarity to previously published work. 这个是指文章和以前的发表的文章内容重复过高吗,以前在这个刊物发表过文章,这次的文章对象和内容以及结论和以前不同,只是部分研究方法比如细胞遗传分子遗传实验部分有相似的地方,是不是这部分需要重写?

3.Please consider rewriting your manuscript and resubmitting it as a short case report. No need to indicate 'literature review' in the title, as the information you have provided is to provide context and does not classify as a literature review本来想投在research 栏目,但是只有几例数据,怕不够所以加了review,但是文章里面没有专门列表review,所以编辑让我考虑rewrite和resubmit,并投在short case report。这种情况下我如果按照编辑的要求重写并重投,机会还有吗,这个杂志有个brief comunication栏目,重投我想投这个栏目,short case report在国内好多单位应该不算业绩吧?虽然老外投case report也不少,他们好像不是很在意。请大神指点迷津!

1 收藏3

全部讨论(0)

默认最新
avatar
1
分享帖子
share-weibo分享到微博
share-weibo分享到微信
认证
返回顶部