dxy logo
首页丁香园病例库全部版块
搜索
登录

【求助】为什么这篇META没有文献质量评价却能发在lancet?

医疗行业从业者 · 最后编辑于 2022-10-09 · IP 广西广西
6090 浏览
这个帖子发布于 14 年零 184 天前,其中的信息可能已发生改变或有所发展。
近日在研究META时,发现一篇META发在了LANCET(IF:30)上,却没有质量评价,想请教各位:
具体如下:
此文发表在LANCET 2006年的某期,题目名为:Fruit and vegetable consumption and stroke: meta-analysis of cohort studies。
除了在纳入标准有一些介绍外,全文再无提到关于quality的说明,更没有相应的质量评价表格:
附:Inclusion and exclusion criteria
For inclusion, studies had to ful?l the following criteria:
have a prospective cohort design; report relative risks or hazard ratios and their corresponding 95% CIs; and provide the frequency of fruit and vegetable consumption. Studies were excluded if: case-control design was used; mixed healthy diet was reported; only two categories of fruit and vegetable intake (eg, daily
vs never) were reported that could not allow for adequate classi?cation of intake.

我目前的解释是:这样的纳入标准已足以证明所纳入的cohort是这个研究这个题目里的最好的文章了,已不再需要质量评价,并且现在的质量评价并不统一。是这样的吗?请教.

附这篇META的全文。











consumption+and+stroke+meta-analysis+of+cohort.pdf (101 KB)
11 40 3

全部讨论(0)

默认最新
avatar
11
分享帖子
share-weibo分享到微博
share-weibo分享到微信
认证
返回顶部